Kamala Harris’s decision to pass over Pete Buttigieg as her running mate during the 2024 election continues to divide opinions and stir controversy.

Harris’s Controversial Decision

In a 2025 interview with Rachel Maddow, Kamala Harris discussed her decision not to choose Pete Buttigieg as her running mate in the 2024 presidential election. Despite her personal preference for Buttigieg, Harris cited the electoral risks of having both a Black woman and an openly gay man on a ticket against Donald Trump. The decision was made just two weeks before the Democratic Convention, with Minnesota Governor Tim Walz ultimately being selected.

Impact on Identity Politics

The decision has reignited discussions around identity politics and strategic risk in campaign planning. Harris’s openness about the role of identity in her decision-making process has been unprecedented, highlighting the intersection of race, gender, and sexuality in high-stakes politics. LGBTQ advocacy groups have expressed mixed reactions—disappointment over the missed opportunity for representation, yet an understanding of the political calculations at play.

Harris emphasized the tight timeline and high stakes of the race, which left little room for risk-taking. Her book “107 Days” provides further insight into the political calculations behind her decision and has become a focal point for ongoing debate.

Future Implications

The controversy surrounding Harris’s decision may have a chilling effect on future tickets featuring multiple “firsts.” This situation underscores the ongoing challenge of balancing representation with perceived electability in American politics. Political strategists note that candidates from marginalized groups often face a “double bind” in high-stakes races, while scholars highlight the tension between these factors. As the Democratic Party continues to grapple with these issues, Buttigieg remains a prominent figure, with eyes on a potential 2028 presidential run.

Kamala Destroys Her Former Running Mate Againhttps://t.co/a2byH3H2YU

— PJ Media (@PJMedia_com) September 24, 2025